>>518219495Bad Back as long as the chance it hobbles you isn't too often or lasts for a long time. Its mostly for the carrying capacity reduction.
Numbskull Although I wish it were more 45% or higher would be ideal.
Hangry Henry, Picky Eater, hunt a dozen or so deer and you'll have enough dried food forever.
Punchable Face maybe but I'm fairly sure there are quests that you'll lose out information on because they surrender.
Heavy-footed.
Somnabulant, was fun in the first game but I hope they have way more locations this time around.
Sweaty sounds annoying, I hate how fast Henry gets dirty and bloody in the first place.
I'd take Bashful if it was just the speech skill reduction.
Menace might be fun, I did plan to play Hardcore as Bad Henry. Although getting arrested and branded because the merchant you saved on the road from bandits saw it as murder doesn't sound fun.
They need to add a few more, one that removes the Pebbles/Herring Perk, reduces the value of goods sold to merchants and makes good doubly expensive, and one that makes it so Henry can't equip most armor that isn't treasure, quest rewards, unique or things he buys himself without getting an "unfitted" debuff or something.